An other Christian site – Een andere Christelijke site

Posts tagged ‘Quakers’

Old and newer King James Versions and other translations #4 Steps to the women’s bibles

Not having enough background of the Jewish Koine Greek, or Jewish Hellenistic Greek, the variety of Koine Greek (hē koinē dialektos ‘the common language’) or “common Attic”  found in a number of Alexandrian dialect texts of Hellenistic Judaism, most notably the Septuagint translation of the Hebrew Bible which at the time of the King James Bible‘s first edition was not yet available, as well as Greek Jewish texts from Palestine. This made that lots of words for previous Bible translations and the Authorised Version, where not yet understood properly and of some words they thought it were persons (names) instead of things (nouns) and situations.

Hellenistic Judaism: historical sites

Important historical sites of Hellenistic and medieval Judaism. – Encyclopædia Britannica, Inc.

Words and word elements were adopted and adapted into Latin over c.1,500 years, and passed through Latin into many European and other languages, being used in the main for scholarly and technical purposes. The flow into English was at first very limited and largely religious, such as Old English cirice and its descendant church (from kūriakón dôma the Lord’s house).


Katharina von Bora (1499–1552) one of the most important participants of the Reformation because of her role in helping to define Protestant family life and setting the tone for clergy marriages.

At the beginning this knowledge of languages was a man’s job, but from the 19th century women began to have their say as well. Lots of Christians have the wrong idea that women in the ancient times had nothing to say. Many also think that in Christianity women played no role at all. they should know that the Set Apart or Holy Scriptures  acknowledges and celebrates the priceless value of a virtuous woman (Proverbs 12:4; 31:10; 1 Corinthians 11:7).

Whilst by the Jews there where not so many women teachers or rabbi’s, from the beginning the master teacher Jeshua had a big heart for them and had many women around him, following him everywhere they could and talking about his actions. The Bible teaches women are not only equals with men (Galatians 3:28), but are also set apart for special honour (1 Peter 3:7). Jeshua also knew how in the past the the priceless value of a virtuous woman was celebrated and insisted those around him to respect the woman also. (Proverbs 12:4; 31:10; 1 Corinthians 11:7).  Not only did the master teacher encourage their discipleship by portraying it as something more needful than domestic service and always treated women with the utmost dignity — even women who might otherwise be regarded as outcasts (Matthew 9:20-22; Luke 7:37-50; John 4:7-27).

“1  After this, Jesus travelled about from one town and village to another, proclaiming the good news of the kingdom of God. The Twelve were with him, 2 and also some women who had been cured of evil spirits and diseases: Mary (called Magdalene) from whom seven demons had come out; 3 Joanna the wife of Chuza, the manager of Herod’s household; Susanna; and many others. These women were helping to support them out of their own means.” (Luke 8:1-3 NIV)

“38  As Jesus and his disciples were on their way, he came to a village where a woman named Martha opened her home to him. 39 She had a sister called Mary, who sat at the Lord’s feet listening to what he said. 40 But Martha was distracted by all the preparations that had to be made. She came to him and asked, “Lord, don’t you care that my sister has left me to do the work by myself? Tell her to help me!” 41 “Martha, Martha,” the Lord answered, “you are worried and upset about many things, 42 but only one thing is needed. Mary has chosen what is better, and it will not be taken away from her.”” (Luke 10:38-42 NIV)

Clearly the listening to Jesus’ teaching was for the rabbi important, because he would not be long with them. for him it was also important that they would know what they had to talk about when he would be gone, because they had to go out into the world and witness about what he had done, and for telling others about the coming Kingdom of God. All those who wanted to be called a disciple or follower of Christ had to witness for him.

“You will be his witness to all men of what you have seen and heard.” (Acts 22:15 NIV)

Already from the start women where there with Jesus.  Christ’s first recorded, explicit disclosure of His own identity as the true Messiah was made to a Samaritan woman (John 4:25-26). When he was gone there were also women present in the room when the Spirit came over the apostles.  From then onwards they too were not afraid any more to come out with their beliefs. Soon they too took also their role in the preaching and some of them even became renowned.

“In Joppa there was a disciple named Tabitha (which, when translated, is Dorcas), who was always doing good and helping the poor.” (Acts 9:36 NIV)

Often it were women who opened up their house for followers of Christ coming together and to lead the meetings.

“When this had dawned on him, he went to the house of Mary the mother of John, also called Mark, where many people had gathered and were praying.” (Acts 12:12 NIV)

Also when things where not so clear for some they dared to call them with them and explain it so they could better understand the truth. Also women who talked about Jesus but did not know everything well, were helped by the apostles so that they could do a better job.

“13 On the Sabbath we went outside the city gate to the river, where we expected to find a place of prayer. We sat down and began to speak to the women who had gathered there. 14 One of those listening was a woman named Lydia, a dealer in purple cloth from the city of Thyatira, who was a worshipper of God. The Lord opened her heart to respond to Paul’s message. 15 When she and the members of her household were baptised, she invited us to her home. “If you consider me a believer in the Lord,” she said, “come and stay at my house.” And she persuaded us.” (Acts 16:13-15 NIV)

Throughout history there have always been faithful women spreading the Word of God.

It might well be that the energetic monk and young theologian Martin Luther, who felt himself to be “a sinner with an unquiet conscience,” was stimulated by the former Benedictine and Cistercian nun Katharina von Bora, who had fled her convent with several other nuns or ‘vestal virgins’, to Wittenberg, and who became, at the age of 26,  his  wife in 1525 (him being 41) and became known as “die Lutherin”.  She became the “boss of Zulsdorf,” after the name of the farm they owned, and the “morning star of Wittenberg” for her habit of rising at 4 a.m. to take care of her various responsibilities, administering and managing the vast holdings of the monastery, breeding and selling cattle, and running a brewery in order to provide for their family and the steady stream of students who boarded with them and visitors seeking audiences with her husband. It can well be that her being at the site of the prosecuted Luther, made him to continue his translation work of the Bible and not giving up his ideas.

In the two following centuries it were women who often took care that the children got to hear the Word of God at home, whilst they were able to hide this sacred book for the persecutors. Those who fled from the European continent to look for a New World also carried with them the Holy Bible in their language or in Latin.

In the 17th century religious groups found their way to the New World and at certain places founded their own colonies so that they could perfectly practice their own faith. Religious liberty for others — a concept Americans would later take for granted — was not part of the Puritans‘ plan. Instead, founding Governor John Winthrop envisioned a model “Citty [sic] upon a hill,” an example of Christian unity and order. Not incidentally, women were expected to play a submissive and supporting role in this society.

Anne Hutchinson, née Anne Marbury

At the Massachusetts Bay Colony a skilled midwife and herbal healer with her own interpretation of Puritan doctrine, challenged the leaders of this “wilderness theocracy,” as Barbara Ritter Dailey describes it.
Anne Hutchinson  [Anne Marbury Hutchinson (1591-1643)] eldest daughter of a strong-willed Anglican priest who had been imprisoned and removed from office because of his demand for a better-educated clergy, had probably inherited the strong will of her father, taking with her a legacy of biblical scholarship and religious independence.

When the Anglican Church silenced one of her favourite teachers, John Cotton, one of England’s outstanding Puritan ministers, one of New England’s first generation, leader in civil and religious affairs, and a persuasive writer on the theory and practice of Congregationalism, left for the colony of Massachusetts in America, Hutchinson became extremely distraught. She finally persuaded her husband to leave for America, so that she could follow her religious mentor.

William Hutchinson was granted a desirable house lot in Boston, and both husband and wife quickly became church members.
When she was criticized for failing to attend weekly prayer meetings in the homes of parishioners, she responded by holding meetings in her own home. She began by reiterating and explaining the sermons of John Cotton but later added some of her own interpretations, a practice that was to be her undoing. As her meetings became more popular, Hutchinson drew some of Boston’s most influential citizens to her home. Many of these were town merchants and artisans who had been severely criticized for profiteering in prices and wages; they saw in Hutchinson’s stress on grace a greater freedom regarding morality and therefore more certainty of their own salvation. But others came in search of a more meaningful and personal relationship with their God. As she attracted followers and defenders, the orthodox Puritans organized to oppose her doctrines and her advocates.

Cotton was chiefly responsible for the exile of Anne Hutchinson, because of her antinomian doctrines, and for the expulsion of Roger Williams.They continued to preach and used their own words. Quoting from the Bible in a non literal way became common practice and would be later taken up in presenting fragments or stories from the Bible. This free telling of Bible stories was also taken up in other languages and was breeding ground for children’s Bibles and freely quoted or paraphrased Bible translations.

The Ritual Dance of the Shakers, Shaker Historical Society

The priests and male clerics mostly kept the bible in their hand and sometimes read some phrases out of it. They still were in the majority, though some ladies walked to the forefront and got followers. It had not all to be literate women who took charge.
An unlettered daughter of a blacksmith who was probably named Lees joined at the age of 22 joined the faith group Shaking Quakers, or Shakers, because of the shaking and dancing that characterized their worship (It originally derived from a small branch of English Quakers founded by Jane and James Wardley in 1747). Ann Lee married in 1762, a union that tradition holds was unhappy and may have influenced her later doctrinal insistence on celibacy. She became the group their accepted leader and was known as Ann the Word or Mother Ann. Although illiterate, she claimed the gift of tongues and the ability to discern spirits and work miracles. She was also convinced of the holiness of celibacy, an idea stemming from her own experience of losing four children at or soon after their birth. In 1774 she led a band of eight to America, where, two years later, at Watervliet, N.Y., the first Shaker settlement in America was founded. The Shaker communities flourished in the mid-19th century and contributed a distinctive style of architecture, furniture, and handicraft to American culture. The communities declined in the late 19th and early 20th centuries. The two American converts who followed Mother Ann as Lead Elder — Joseph Meacham (1787–1796) and Lucy Wright (1796–1821) — developed an institutional structure for less antagonistic relations with society.

At that time, a woman’s leadership of a religious group was considered to be a ‘sect leader’ and as a radical departure from Protestant Christianity. Living apart from her husband Elizur Goodrich, she like him committed herself fully to Shakerism and within a decade rose to leadership within the Shakers movement, with the power and authority which women were not allowed in other religions.

Wright was fully aware of our task of witnessing and sent missionaries to preach across New England and upstate New York as well as into the western wilderness, where those preachers recruited proselytes and established new Shaker villages in Kentucky, Ohio, and Indiana.
Under Wright’s administration, Shakers standardized and increased book and tract publishing for the widely-scattered religious society. Their first statement of beliefs was Testimony of Christ’s Second Appearing in 1810, followed by a hymnal which served much the same purpose in 1813. This way the bible-fragments were brought to the general public in ordinary simple words.

In the early nineteenth century the movement expanded into Ohio, Indiana, and Kentucky. By the mid-1820s about 4,000 believers lived in sixteen communal villages, usually with residential “Great Houses” surrounded by meetinghouses, barns, mills, workshops, and smaller residences for children and probationary members. A hierarchy of elders and eldresses who had completely abandoned the sinful world were in charge.

Charles g finney.jpg

Charles Grandison Finney (1792–1875) American Presbyterian minister and leader in the Second Great Awakening in the United States.

In the New World several Female Missionary Societies saw the light and invited men as well as women to proclaim the Word of God.  The Female Missionary Society of the Western District hired in this way Charles Grandison Finney who came to promote social reforms, such as abolition of slavery and equal education for women and African Americans. From 1835 he taught at Oberlin College of Ohio, which accepted all genders and races, opening the way for more women able to read the Bible.

The Christians who believed only in One God and wanted others also to know the biblical truth, saw with dismay how Finney used scare tactics to gain converts.

Across the board, many thought that his habitual use of the words you and hell “let down the dignity of the pulpit.” {Charles Finney Father of American revivalism}

During the 16th and 17th century Anabaptists were heavily prosecuted in Europe because of their view of Jesus his position and man’s position in this world. By the many searchers for the truth lots of them found they could not take on the human doctrines like the Trinity and found that people had to be fully aware of what believing meant and when to commit themselves to the Only One God. From the Low countries many went to America. On the boat-trip they had a very good opportunity to speak about the biblical truth to others form different denominations. also the English doctor John Thomas who as ship’s surgeon on the Marquis of Wellesley, took the occasion to share his ideas with many people on board. When this boat docked in New York, Thomas travelled on to Cincinnati, Ohio where he became convinced by the Restoration Movement (also known as the or the Stone-Campbell Movement) of the need for baptism and joined them in October 1832. Looking for the “church within” we can imagine that people tried also to express themselves freely to show others how they understood the Word of God.

The Restoration Movement developed from several independent strands of religious revival that idealized apostolic Christianity. They were united in the belief that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God. After his bad experience fearing for his life when the boat had nearly sunk, Thomas took his vow to God seriously and went going from one place to another, preaching the Word of God. Many of his followers came to “the Brotherhood”, and started to have meetings in their houses or barns to study the Word of God. For them it was clear that human doctrines and church creeds divide and that real Christians should be under Christ. for them God’s Word was clearly given to all people and the Bible was not to be the matter only for clergy. For them all Christians should take the Bible as their guide and leader and should suppress all divisive doctrines and practices.

One of Thomas his disciples would find enough people interested to print pamphlets and tracts. He also started as a Christian restorationist minister and became better known as Pastor Russell, being the instigator of Russellism or founder of the Russellites, opposite the Thomasites or followers of Dr. Thomas who founded the Christadelphians, Brothers in Christ who took studying the bible as one of their priorities (hence the other name Bible Students).

Dr Thomas also wrote for and was editor of the Apostolic Advocate which first appeared in May 1834, whilst Charles Taze Russell started only in July 1879 with publishing his monthly religious journal, Zion’s Watch Tower and Herald of Christ’s Presence. In 1881 he co-founded Zion’s Watch Tower Tract Society with William Henry Conley as president, providing the establishment of an international Bible Student movement. In 1884 the corporation was officially registered, with Russell as president. From then onwards those Bible Students tried to bring Bible fragments in the common language of the day. For them women had also their say and were worthy co-operators to produce articles and to bring bible texts in contemporary American English.

It was his successor as society president, Joseph Rutherford who brought a wide division in the Bible student movement and created the Jehovah’s Witnesses who would work at translating the Word of God, doing a marvellous job, presenting bibles in many languages all over the world, so that nobody would have an excuse he or she could not find a Bible in a language he or she understands.


Mary Jane Patterson (1840–1894)

In 1862 Mary Jane Patterson became the first African-American woman to receive a B.A degree in the New World. She received a recommendation for an “appointment from the American missionary Association as a … teacher among freedmen.” In 1865 Patterson became an assistant to Fanny Jackson Coppin at the Philadelphia’s Institute for Colored Youth (now Cheyney University of Pennsylvania). In 1869 to 1871 Patterson taught in Washington, D. C., at the Preparatory High School for Colored Youth known today as Dunbar High School (Washington, D.C.). She served as the school’s first Black principal, from 1871 to 1872. She was reappointed from 1873 to 1884. During her administration, the school grew from less than 50 to 172 students, the name “Preparatory High School” was dropped, high school commencements were initiated, and a teacher-training department was added to the school. Patterson’s commitment to thoroughness as well as her “forceful” and “vivacious” personality helped her establish the school’s strong intellectual standards.
We can imagine by those standards being a Christian life style and good moral where essence.

Already around the turn of the 18th to 19th century women had started wanting to have a stronger voice in the education of children. Also parents started looking more at how to bring up children together in a community. They had seen the public school system starting to develop going away from certain ways of life preferred by them. The spiritual aspect was important and could not be forgotten. Discontented with the new public school system more alternative education developed in part as a reaction to perceived limitations and failings of traditional education. In many of such schools at that time the Bible and Christian life formed an important element of educational basic training. A broad range of educational approaches emerged, including alternative schools, self learning, homeschooling and unschooling.

Benjamin Wilson (1817–1900)

In 1840 the English family Wilson though originally Baptists, joined the growing Campbellite movement and moved to the New World four years later. In Geneva, Illinois the family began to distance themselves from the Campbellites. In 1846 Benjamin Wilson wrote his first letter to the other ex-Campbellite John Thomas, as recorded in the latter’s magazine The Herald of the Future Age, agreeing with the Thomas’ views on the immortal soul – the initial cause of his break with Campbell. There is considerable correspondence in Thomas’ magazines from various members of the Wilson family over the next several years.

Just as John Thomas had been re-baptised in 1847, Benjamin Wilson was rebaptised in 1851, marking off a new start from the Campbellites.

The first page of the Complutensian Polyglot

From 1855 to 1869 Benjamin Wilson published a monthly religious magazine, the Gospel Banner, which merged with John Thomas’s magazine, Herald of the Coming Kingdom.

In 1857 the autodidact Biblical scholar Benjamin Wilson presented a first section of a side-by-side two-language New Testament version like the New Testament in Greek and Latin, had been completed in 1514 with the Complutensian printed by Axnaldus Guilielmus de Brocario at the expense of Cardinal Ximenes at the university at Alcalá de Henares (Complutum) and the Antwerp Polyglot, printed by Christopher Plantin (1569-1572, in eight volumes folio). Polyglot means, literally poly or multi tongue or multi lingual, “through tongue” or “many / several languages” and is understood to signify “interlinear.”

In England there had also been a polyglot translation by Brian Walton who was aided by able scholars and used much new manuscript material (London, 1657). It included the Ethiopic Psalter, Canticle of Canticles, and New Testament, the Arabic New Testament, and the Gospels in Persian. His prolegomena and collections of various readings mark an important advance in biblical criticism.

It was in connection with this polyglot that Edmund Castell produced his famous Heptaglott Lexicon (two volumes folio, London, 1669), a monument of industry and erudition even when allowance is made for the fact that for the Arabic he had the great manuscript lexicon compiled and left to the University of Cambridge by William Bedwell. {Free Encyclopedia Wikipedia}

The Emphatic Diaglott.jpgThe Bible was also published in several languages by Elias Hutter (Nuremberg, 1599-1602), and by Christianus Reineccius (Leipsic, 1713-51). Ten years before the “Polyglot Bible in eight languages” (2 vols., London, 2nd ed. 1874) the Christadelphians produced the complete two-language Emphatic Diaglott translation, of the New Testament by Benjamin Wilson. For the Greek text he based it on the various Readings of the Vatican Manuscript, No. 1209; the text used by the German rationalist Protestant theologian Johann Jakob Griesbach, who was the earliest biblical critic to subject the Gospels to systematic literary analysis. In this translation the name of God is also restored, so that readers could clearly see about whom was spoke and who said something, the lord Jeshua (Jesus Christ) or the Lord of lords”Jehovah“.

In this Interlineary literal Word for Word English translation ‘Signs of Emphasis’ were given; whilst under each Greek word the English equivalent is printed. In the slim right-hand column of each page is presented a modern English translation as made by Benjamin Wilson. Also a copious selection of ‘References’; many appropriate, illustrative, and exegetical ‘Foot-notes’; and a valuable ‘Alphabetical Appendix’ are given. This combination of important items could not be found in any other book at that time.

Such literal translations made many bible Students to see much things more clearly. Also Charles T. Russell, learned that the inspired Greek Scriptures speak of the second “presence” of Christ, for the Diaglott translated the Greek word “parousía” correctly as “presence,” and not as “coming” like the King James Version Bible. Accordingly when C. T. Russell began publishing his new Bible magazine in July of 1879, he called it Zion’s Watch Tower and Herald of Christ’s Presence.

The Christadelphians allowed also the Millenial Dawn Bible Students (later the Watchtower Society) to distribute Wilson’s work widely around the world from 1902. Also the Church of God of the Abrahamic Faith and the Church of the Blessed Hope which he founded are still part of the Christadelphian movement which still print this Bible translation.

Bible students form the Zion’s Watchtower suggested that,

Every student of God’s plan, as presented in the Tower, ought to have the aid which the Diaglott affords.

As such this translation became a useful attribute for the later standard Bible of the Jehovah’s Witnesses, The New World Translation.

In 2004, the Abrahamic Faith Beacon Publishing Society brought home The Emphatic Diaglott and re-published a new version of it, working in partnership with The Christadelphian Advancement Trust.

In the homeschooling opposite to traditional Christian schools it were mostly women who took up the job as teacher. Having only bibles in Old English they wanted books in a more contemporary language and put pressure on the existing clergy. From the congregations also came a louder cry to provide them with modern language bibles.

King James Version of the Bible

King James Version of the Bible (Photo credit: Wikipedia)

Answering that cry from the housewives and teachers in 1870 an invitation was extended to American religious leaders for scholars to work on the revision of the Authorized Version/King James Bible of 1611. In 1871, thirty scholars were chosen by Philip Schaff. The denominations represented on the American committee were the Baptist, Congregationalist, Dutch Reformed, Friends, Methodist, Episcopal, Presbyterian, Protestant Episcopal, and Unitarian.

In England also there was a request to have a revision and by the Convocation of Canterbury in 1870 two companies were formed, one each for the Old and New Testaments to revise the King James Version. Parallel companies in the United States received the work of the English scholars to return their comments. For those at work it was made clear only a revision and not a new translation was contemplated.

The New Testament was published in England on May 17, 1881, and three days later in the United States, after 11 years of labour. Over 30,000 changes were made, of which more than 5,000 represent differences in the Greek text from that used as the basis of the King James Version. Most of the others were made in the interests of consistency or modernization.

In the traditional churches there was not much interest in the Old Testament, this not fitting in with the accent of their teaching on Jesus, instead of God.

On certain points the English and Americans did not agree. At that time the Americans still gave in to the British revisers and published preferred readings and renderings in an appendix to the Revised Version. In 1900 the American edition of the New Testament, which incorporated the American scholars’ preferences into the body of the text, was produced. A year later the Old Testament was added, but not the Apocrypha. The alterations covered a large number of obsolete words and expressions and replaced Anglicisms by the diction then in vogue in the United States.

As shown above women and the general American public made use to talk about the Bible and to use it at home. The publishers could not ignore their wishes and provided them with some official version which could offer an alternative for the partly published Bible books and for the unofficial translations into modern speech made from 1885 which had gained popularity. Their appeal reinforced by the discovery that the Greek of the New Testament used the common non-literary variety of the language spoken throughout the Roman Empire when Christianity was in its formative stage.

The notion that a nonliterary modern rendering of the New Testament best expressed the form and spirit of the original was hard to refute. This, plus a new maturity of classical, Hebraic, and theological scholarship in the United States, led to a desire to produce a native American version of the English Bible. {Encyclopaedia Britannica}


Preceding articles:

Old and newer King James Versions and other translations #1 Pre King James Bible

Old and newer King James Versions and other translations #2 King James Bible versions

Old and newer King James Versions and other translations #3 Women and versions

Next: Old and newer King James Versions and other translations #5 Further steps to women’s bibles


Additional reading

  1. Codex Sinaiticus available for perusal on the Web
  2. Bible Translating and Concordance Making
  3. Looking at notes of Samuel Ward and previous Bible translation efforts in English
  4. Written and translated by different men over thousands of years
  5. Rare original King James Bible discovered
  6. King James Bible Coming into being
  7. Celebrating the Bible in English
  8. TheBible4Life KJV Jubileum
  9. What English Bible do you use?
  10. The Most Reliable English Bible
  11. 2001 Translation an American English Bible
  12. NWT and what other scholars have to say to its critics
  13. New American Bible Revised Edition
  14. The NIV and the Name of God
  15. Archeological Findings the name of God YHWHUse of /Gebruik van Jehovah or/of Yahweh in Bible Translations/Bijbel vertalingen
  16. Dedication and Preaching Effort 400 years after the first King James Version
  17. Hebrew, Aramaic and Bibletranslation
  18. Some Restored Name Versions
  19. Anchor Yale Bible
  20. iPod & Android Bibles
  21. Missed opportunity for North Korea
  22. What are Brothers in Christ
  23. Wanting to know more about basic teachings of Christadelphianism
  24. Around C.T.Russell


Further reading

  1. Jennifer Strauss, ‘The Anabaptist Cages, Münster’
  2. The Bible: Kept Pure in All Ages
  3. Where was the Bible before 1611? How can we know God endorsed the KJV?
  4. AV1611: England’s Greatest Achievement
  5. Earliest Known Draft of 1611 King James Bible Is Found
  6. Ye King Iames Bible
  7. King James Version
  8. Thees, Thous, and Wot Nots
  9. The King James Bible
  10. The King James Bible and the Restoration
  11. King James Only? (Ethernal Christ)
  12. KJV Only? (Lynn Thaler)
  13. KJV Onlyism: What It Does And Doesn’t Mean
  14. King James XV
  15. Christian Scholars Admit To Corrupting The Bible
  16. What’s wrong with the New King James?
  17. Is it true no doctrines are changed in modern versions?
  18. The King James AV 1611 Bible vs. The New International Version
  19. I got saved reading the NIV. How can you say it’s no good?
  20. Why should God’s Word be restricted to English?
  21. The Attack on the Bible
  22. John 3:16 isn’t the gospel that saves men’s souls today
  23. New Age Deism
  24. New Age Deism: Part Two
  25. Inside Orthodox Judaism: A Critical Perspective On Its Theology
  26. Mailbox Monday August 29: on Katharina von Bora
  27. 11th April 1612. Dangerous Heresy.
  28. Book Review: The Reformers and Their Stepchildren by Leonard Verduin
  29. women.born.before | 05 feb 1760
  30. Settler Colonialism and the Freedom of Religion
  31. Searching for Religious Freedom
  32. Freedom From and For Religion
  33. This Week in History – Kicked to the Curb by a Pilgrim
  34. King Survey: Women and Other Puritans
  35. The Puritans: Church and State
  36. Midweek Blog: Anne Hutchinson, the “Unnatural Woman”
  37. Paddling the Hutch: Ned P. Rauch takes the plunge
  38. Great Information Wrapped Inside This Human Struggle
  39. The Puritan identification with the Bible
  40. Despite Roger Williams’ Efforts, Providence Burns in 1676
  41. Williams
  42. Roger Williams in Art
  43. Mass Moments: Roger Williams Banished
  44. Research Reading IV
  45. Research Reading V
  46. History Weekend: The Shakers, pt. 1
  47. Quakers
  48. Commonwealth – Part Two
  49. A Catalogue of Severall Sects & Opinions
  50. History of the Anabaptist Head Covering
  51. Faith in the Head Covering
  52. Persecuted in Revolutionary Baltimore: The Sufferings of Quakers
  53. Half an hour in James Watt’s Workshop
  54. The Advices & Queries project
  55. The Violent Seduction of Thomas Paine by Rocket Kirchner
  56. The Last Runaway Review
  57. Stantons in America
  58. Eber Sherman, ,7th Great-Grandfather
  59. Birmingham Quakers and the Spanish Civil War
  60. Hidden Nearby: Charles Grandison Finney’s Birthplace
  61. Free Charles Finney Book!
  62. The reward of fervent prayer, Charle G. Finney
  63. Midweek Blog: Charles Finney, Staring at You Until You Join His Revival
  64. “Could God Forgive A Man Like That?”
  65. Joseph Logan land, 127 acres, Ninety Six District, South Carolina, 1785
  66. Alexander Campbell & the Indwelling of the Holy Spirit
  67. Restoration
  68. The Restoration Movement, Acapella & the Trinity
  69. The Future of the Restoration Movement, Part 2
  70. Charles Taze Russell – “Don’t read your Bible”
  71. Apocalyptic Forecasts
  72. Women’s History: Mary Jane Patterson
  73. Some Notes on Bible Translations
  74. What is Wrong with Evangelicals in America?
  75. For Us or Against Us: The Politics of the Christian Right & the Shutdown
  76. Icon: Tacy Cooper
  77. The Secret of Powerful Revivals Are the Intercessors Praying Behind the Scenes
  78. Les origines de nos traditions dans l’Eglise : Partie 1
  79. Edifying Christian Biographies That Will Bless Every True Christian!
  80. A Visit to Pembroke College
  81. Hospitality
  82. ‘Tis a Gift
  83. A weekend away
  84. Simple gifts
  85. Becoming Visible: Quaker Outreach at Colleges
  86. Turbulent Londoners: Ada Salter, 1866-1942
  87. A Spicy Letter to Preachers
  88. On Church Leadership (an email exchange with Sándor Abonyi of Hungary) – Pt.1: “The First Button”
  89. My way is the best
  90. ELCA Repudiates the Doctrine of Discovery, Next Up: Mennonite Church USA
  91. A glimpse of Missouri’s Amish
  92. Freedom of religion
  93. Book Review – Recovering the Margins of American Religious History: The Legacy of David Edwin Harrell, Jr. (Waldrop and Billingsley, eds.)
  94. Book Review: The Churches of Christ in the 20th Century: Homer Hailey’s Personal Journey of Faith (David Edwin Harrell, Jr.)
  95. Churches of Christ – The Road Ahead
  96. Some Notes on Bible Translations




Broeders en Zusters in Christus door de eeuwen heen #12 Anabaptisten


De Lyonese koopman, Petrus Waldo (of Waldus, ook Valdez)(ca. 1140-1206) las in het evangelie volgens Mattheus 19:21 dat Jezus een rijke jongeman opdraagt al zijn bezit te verkopen ten bate van de armen. Waldo raakte hiervan zo onder de indruk dat hij besloot dit voorbeeld te volgen. Hij gaf zijn bezit aan de armen en ging prediken. Gelijkaardig aan de arme priesters van Engeland vindt hij dat een goed christen een bezitloos en arm leven moet leiden.

Petrus Waldo

Waldes’ volgelingen trokken rond op sandalen in de Provence, Languedoc, Sicilië en in de dalen van Piemonte bij Torino, waarbij mannen èn vrouwen predikten.  Hier komt duidelijk de opvolging van Christus leer om te prediken naar voor, waarbij er totaal geen sprake is van een geestelijke hiërarchie. Het zijn allemaal Broeders van Christus die Jezus’ voorbeeld navolgen en de Blijde boodschap verkondigen. Omdat zij dit als leken deden, veroordeelde de paus paus Lucius III hen op het concilie van Verona in 1184 als ketters. Hij herhaalde dit op het concilie van Lateranen in 1215 nog eens. Doordat ze in de ban werden gedaan, werden ze eeuwenlang vervolgd en werden tienduizenden Waldenzen vermoord. Toch nam hun aantal toe in Zuid-Frankrijk en Noord-Italië. Aanvankelijk werden zij gesteund door de Zuid-Franse adel, die zich op deze wijze los wilde maken van de koning van Frankrijk. Het meest bekende bloedbad is dat van Mérindol en Cabrières in de Zuidelijke Luberon in 1545. Door het Edict van Nantes uit 1598 kregen de protestanten in Frankrijk godsdienstvrijheid, maar Lodewijk XIV herriep dit edict in 1685, waardoor er opnieuw een verdrukkingsgolf ontstond. Er werd een kruistocht tegen de Waldenzen gericht. Ze verborgen zich echter in de dalen van de Alpen, ten zuidwesten van Turijn. De groep telde ongeveer 700 mensen. Het koninklijk leger probeerde hen daar te verslaan, waarna er slechts 250 mensen over waren.

Pijniging van Waldenzen te Atrecht, Luyken, Casper (1672-1708) 1700 prent

Als ernstige Bijbelonderzoekers en Bijbelgetrouwen vonden de Waldenzen dat zij zich niet mochten verzetten met geweld en verwierpen de wapendracht. Zij wensten ook geen eden af te leggen en onthielden zich van en allerlei kathaarse theorieën en kerkelijke gewoonten zoals aflaatpraktijken en het opdragen van missen voor de overledenen.

Uit de Waldenzen ontstonden doopsgezinde broeders. Omstreeks het jaar 1525 traden de anabaptisten voor het eerst op de voorgrond, en wel in Zürich (Zwitserland). Vanuit die stad verbreidden hun geloofsovertuigingen zich snel naar veel delen van Europa. De vroege zestiende-eeuwse Reformatie had enkele veranderingen teweeggebracht, maar naar de mening van de anabaptisten was men niet ver genoeg gegaan. De doopsgezinden waren onafhankelijke Broeders in Christus. Doordat er geen hierarchie was of een algemeen besturend orgaan vormden zij een  beweging met een groot aantal verschillende groepen met eigen theologische opvattingen. Doch kan men stellen dat de belangrijkste gemeenschappelijke kenmerken van de dopers de opvatting is dat wedergeboorte de voorwaarde is voor het toedienen van de doop. Om wedergeborente kunnen worden moet men besef hebben van wat men gedaan heeft.  Als men het leven is ingegaan is men geboren, maar als men tot Jezus Christus komt en zich wil overgeven aan God kan men tot een wedergeboorte komen. Met volheid van verstand kan men enkel die keuze maken. Daarom kan men alleen volwassenen dopen. Omdat men zelfs aan iemand die als baby was gedoopt verzocht zich te laten “herdopen”, gaf men hun de naam „anabaptisten”, wat „wederdopers” betekent.  (Matthéüs 28:19; Handelingen 2:41; 8:12; 10:44-48)

Groepsdoop in een rivier van de Anabaptisten, schilderij van Jeanron

De onafhankelijke opstelling, in het verlengde van de gedachte van de Waldenzen en “poor priests” of “arme priesters” maakte dat zij ook een kerk zagen als een vereniging op basis van vrijwilligheid, los van invloed van de staat, waartoe mensen als zij tot de jaren van verstand waren gekomen konden toetreden. Zij die gedoopt waren moesten dit doopsel ook tot uiting brengen in hun geloof en hun daden. Zij moesten geen academisch geschoolde theologen worden, maar het prediken moest in hun hart en op hun tong liggen. Op deze punten braken de dopers met de middeleeuwse traditie waarin de samenleving gezien werd als een christelijke maatschappij (het corpus christianum) en liepen zij vooruit op de moderne scheiding van kerk en staat.

In hun verlangen tot de christelijke leer van de eerste eeuw terug te keren, verwierpen zij meer van het rooms-katholieke dogma dan Maarten Luther en andere hervormers hadden gedaan.

„Voor de anabaptisten was de ware Kerk een gemeenschap van gelovigen”, schrijft dr. R. J. Smithson in zijn boek The AnabaptistsTheir Contribution to Our Protestant Heritage.Als zodanig beschouwden zij zich als een vereniging van gelovigen binnen de gemeenschap als geheel, en in het begin kenden zij geen speciaal opgeleide of betaalde predikanten. Evenals Jezus’ discipelen waren zij rondtrekkende predikers die steden en dorpen bezochten en de mensen aanspraken op de markt, in werkplaatsen en in huizen. (Matthéüs 9:35; 10:5-7, 11-13; Lukas 10:1-3). Voor hen moesten er geen speciale kerkgebouwen zijn om God te aanbidden en kon dat even goed in een schuur gedaan worden, wat dan ook meermaals gebeurde om de vele volgelingen op te vangen.

Anabaptist martelaar Maria van Beckum haar broeders vrouw, 1554

Men ging ervan uit dat elke anabaptist persoonlijk rekenschap verschuldigd was aan God, dat hij een vrije wil bezat en zijn geloof door middel van zijn werken toonde maar toch wist dat redding niet alleen door werken werd verkregen. Als iemand tegen het geloof zondigde, kon hij uit de gemeente worden geworpen, want voor hen was het belangrijk dat de gehele gemeenschap zuiver bleef. Verschillen in opvatting over de omgang met zondaars en de mate van wereldmijding leidden tot een grote versplintering van de beweging. Herstel volgde alleen nadat oprecht berouw was getoond. (1 Korinthiërs 5:11-13; vergelijk 2 Korinthiërs 12:21).

Net als de vroege christenen werden ook de anabaptisten niet begrepen. En net als de vroege christenen werden zij beschouwd als personen die de gevestigde maatschappelijke orde verstoorden en ’de bewoonde aarde ondersteboven keerden’ (Handelingen 17:6). In Zürich kantten de autoriteiten, die aan de zijde stonden van de hervormer Huldrych Zwingli, zich vooral tegen de anabaptisten omdat zij de kinderdoop verwierpen. In 1527 brachten zij Felix Mantz, een van de anabaptistische leiders, op wrede wijze door verdrinking om het leven en vervolgden zij de Zwitserse anabaptisten zo hevig, dat zij bijna werden uitgeroeid.

In Duitsland werden de anabaptisten zowel door de katholieken als de protestanten hevig vervolgd. Een keizerlijke verordening, die in het jaar 1528 werd uitgevaardigd, bepaalde dat een ieder die anabaptist werd, zonder enige vorm van proces ter dood gebracht zou worden. De vervolging in Oostenrijk deed de meeste aldaar woonachtige anabaptisten hun toevlucht zoeken in Moravië, Bohemen en Polen, en later in Hongarije en Rusland.

Toen zo veel oorspronkelijke leiders stierven, was het onvermijdelijk dat extremisten op de voorgrond traden. Zij brachten een onevenwichtigheid met zich mee die aanleiding gaf tot veel verwarring en tot gevolg had dat men de maatstaven die men in de beginperiode had gehanteerd, liet varen. Dit trad op tragische wijze aan het licht in het jaar 1534, toen de extremisten met geweld het stadsbestuur van Münster (Westfalen) overnamen. Het jaar daarop werd de stad na veel bloedvergieten en martelingen heroverd. Deze episode strookte niet met de werkelijke anabaptistische leer en heeft er veel toe bijgedragen hen in diskrediet te brengen. Sommige gelovigen trachtten zich van de naam anabaptisten te ontdoen door zich „baptisten” te noemen. Maar welke naam zij ook kozen, zij werden toch nog het slachtoffer van oppositie en in het bijzonder van de katholieke inquisitie.

Melchior Hofmann (ca. 1500 – 1543) van oorsprong een Lutherse lekenprediker hield er chiliastische ideeën op na, wat inhield dat hij er in geloofde dat na de wederkomst van Christus een duizendjarig vrederijk en/of een paradijs op aarde zou vestigen. Met zijn apocalyptische preken en geschriften had hij grote invloed op het ontstaan van het doperse rijk van Münster in 1534 onder leiding van de door Jan Matthijs gedoopte Jan van Leiden (Jan of Johan Beukelsz van Leiden, Johann Bockelson of Johan Beukelszoon) (15091536) die het niet zo nauw nam met getrouwheid aan één vrouw en er 17 tot zich nam.

Melchior Hofmann

De Haarlemse bakker Jan Matthijs (ook bekend als Jan Matthias, Johan Mathijszoon) (ca. 15001534) was rond 1520 door toedoen van Melchior Hoffman wederdoper geworden. Deze laatste had Matthijs met zijn toekomstvisioenen geïnspireerd. Nadat Hoffman gevangen was gezet werd Matthijs een vooraanstaand leider bij de wederdopers. Hij stuurde Jan van Leiden als apostel naar Münster om de wederdopers aldaar te ondersteunen. De geweldloosheid die Hoffman had uitgedragen werd door Matthijs verworpen. Hij was de mening toegedaan dat bij onderdrukking gewapend verzet geoorloofd was. Met Jan van Leiden en Bernhard Rottmann probeerde hij in Münster een “Duizendjarig vrederijk” te stichten, dat nog geen twee jaar duurde.

Hofmann, die rondreisde in Oost-Friesland en Holland tot 1532 als prediker, wist daar de grondslag te leggen voor een sterke doperse beweging en zijn ideaal van de geweldloosheid werd overgenomen door de latere Friese doperse leider Menno Simons (ca. 14961561), een voormalig rooms-katholiek priester die door heel het Duitse taalgebied christelijke gemeenten oprichtte. deze ging ook uit van het zuivere apostelschap van de christelijke gemeente die volledig zuiver moest gehouden worden, ‘zonder vlek of rimpel’ (Efezen5:27) . Zijn volgelingen worden nu als oudste nog bestaande doperse kerk beschouwd en zijn gekend origine Doopsgezinden. Die mennonieten of mennisten vallen op door hun ouderwetse kledij en gebruiken omdat zij alle hedendaagse ‘onnatuurlijke” hulpmiddelen afzweren. Het streven naar een geweldloze wereld, het weigeren van de eed en de persoonlijke belijdenis van mondige mensen, in plaats van het onderschrijven van de door de kerk vastgelegde teksten is gebleven. Zij kennen noch steeds geen ambtsdragers zoals er ook geen zijn bij de Christadelphians, waar ook niets moet maar mag. De predikanten worden beschouwd als gewoon lid van de gemeente te midden van alle anderen. In 2004 waren er ongeveer 1 miljoen mennonieten en 1,5 miljoen in 2006 met de grootste groeperingen in Canada, de Democratische Republiek van Congo and the Verenigde  Staten van Amerika.

Ten slotte emigreerden groepen anabaptisten, op zoek naar meer vrijheid en vrede. Op het ogenblik treffen wij hen zowel in Noord- en Zuid-Amerika als in Europa aan. Veel groeperingen hebben een zekere invloed ondervonden van hun vroege leerstellingen, zoals onder andere het door George Fox in 1649 opgerichte “Genootschap der Vrienden” dikwijls beter gekend onder de naam Quakers.Verder baptisten en de Plymouth Brethren. De quakers delen de door de anabaptisten gekoesterde haat ten opzichte van oorlog en de gedachte van leiding door een ’innerlijk licht’.

Not a mennonite

Mennonitische zusters

De anabaptisten bestaan thans voornamelijk voort in twee specifieke groeperingen. De eerste is die der Hutterse Broeders, genoemd naar hun zestiende-eeuwse leider Jacob Hutter. In de quakergemeenschap in Nederland, evenals elders in de wereld, bestaan verschillende affiniteiten waaronder een evangelische, vrijzinnig-christelijke en universalistische. Zoals de de minder radicale Mennonietische hoofdstroom en de Alsaser Anabaptistische  schismatise strekking van Jakob Amman (16441730) de Old Order Mennonite en de groep beter gekend onder de naam Amish (Amisch, Amische) of Amish Mennonites heeft men enkele Quaker groeperingen die het werelds genot verwerpen en een ascetisch leven nastreven. Veel Amish gemeenschappen emigreerden  vanaf 1737 vanuit Europa  naar Noord-Amerika omdat hun levenswijze in Europa vaak nauwelijks getolereerd werd. Dit gebeurde onder invloed van de uitnodiging van William Penn die ook de andere religieuze minderheden zoals Quakers en Hernhutters had gevraagd om naar zijn kolonie Pennsylvania in Noord-Amerika te komen om zich daar te vestigen. Zo’n 500 Amish gingen op deze uitnodiging in. In de 19e eeuw, als reactie op politieke (Franse Revolutie) en economische (Industriële revolutie) veranderingen, volgden nog eens 3.000 personen. Als gevolg hiervan stonden in 2005 zo’n 224.000 Amish geregistreerd in 22 Amerikaanse staten, waarvan het merendeel in Pennsylvania, Ohio en Indiana waar zij nog Pennsylvania Dutch of Pennsylvania German spreken. Dezen hebben wel districten die  worden geleid door een bisschop, enkele ministers en diaken.  Hun leden zijn wel gebonden door opgelegde strengen gemeenschapsregels: de Ordnung. Deze regels bedekken de meeste aspecten van het dagelijkse leven en omvatten verboden of beperkingen op het gebruik van elektrische leidingselektriciteit, telefoons en auto’s evenals voorschriften op kledij. Alsook wordt er de voorkeur gehouden zich afstandelijk te houden van de rest van de wereld. Behalve voor een tijdelijk moment wanneer de jongeren voor de beslissing om over te gaan tot hun doop even in de wereld worden losgelaten om zo hun keuze te bepalen. Deze kennismaking met de rest van de wereld tijdens adolescentie wordt rumspringa (Rumschpringe of Rumshpringa) of “rondlopen” genoemd. Niet alle amishe mennonieten gebruiken deze term (in de verlengde discussie over adolescentie treft men het niet aan bij die van Hostetler) , maar in groepen die het wel doen wordt deze tijd door de amishe ouderen aanschouwd als een tijd voor verkering en het vinden van een echtgenoot/echtgenote. Bij de Amish die zich verzette tegen autogebruik werd de Groffdale Conferentie mennonietische  Kerk of Groffdale Conference Mennonite Church (die ook naar Bisschop Joseph Wenger is genoemd). De rest van de Weaverland Conferentie is gekend onder de naam Horning Church of “Black-bumped Mennonites” (Zwart-Verdrongen mennonieten) voor hun vroegere gewoonte om van hun gekochte auto’s het opzichtige chroom met zwarte verf te verdoezelen.

Mennonitisch zusters anno 2011 zonder gordel

Tag Cloud

Age To Come

The Lord Jesus Christ is the last Adam, not the first God-man. ~~~


I go undercover in the Jehovah's Witness Church

Jehovah's Zsion, Zion and Sion Mom Signal for the Peoples!

Thy Empire and Kingdom Zsion Come as In Heavens So on Earth. Diatheke. Matthew.6.10, Tanakh.Psalm.87 and


Doxology rooted in Theology: Nothing more, Nothing less


A discussion of interesting books from my current stock at

Unmasking anti Jehovah sites and people

Showing the only One True God and the Way to That God

The Eccentric Fundamentalist

Musings on theology, apologetics, practical Christianity and God's grace in salvation through Jesus Christ

John 20:21

"As the Father has sent me, so I am sending you."

The Biblical Review

Reviewing Publications, History, and Biblical Literature

Words on the Word

Blog by Abram K-J


Hier bestudeer ons die redes vir die verskille in Bybelvertalings.

Michael Bradley - Time Traveler

The official website of Michael Bradley - Author of novels, short stories and poetry involving the past, future, and what may have been.


"Be faithful unto death, and I will give you the crown of life." Revelation 2:10

God's Simple Kindness

God's Word Made Simple


All the Glory to God

Groen is Gezond

van zaadjes in volle grond tot iets lekkers op het bord

Jesse A. Kelley

A topnotch site


JW Current Apostate Status and Final Temple Judgment - Web Witnessing Record; The Bethel Apostasy is Prophecy

Sophia's Pockets

Wisdom Withouth Walls


Spiritual Shots to Fuel the Conqueror Lifestyle

%d bloggers like this: